x
x
Steel strengthening application on a reinforced concrete structure

Steel strengthening is the increasing of capacity by adding steel members to an existing reinforced concrete system. Because it is based on fabricating the parts in a workshop and erecting them on site, it progresses far more quickly than wet construction. That speed creates a decisive advantage in buildings that remain in use.

In this article we explain the forms in which steel strengthening is applied, which deficiencies it addresses, why the connection details are so critical, and matters such as fire and corrosion that must not be neglected.

quote

In steel strengthening it is not the section that carries the load but the connection. An anchor that cannot transfer load from the concrete to the steel turns even the heaviest section into decoration.

Ahmet Toka, General Manager

Forms of Application

Steel is added to a structure for different purposes and in different forms. Each answers a different deficiency.

Steel Collar (Wrapping)

A cage formed around a column with angles and horizontal flats. By confining the column from outside it limits the lateral expansion of the concrete; this increases the axial capacity and, most importantly, the ductility. It is an effective solution for old columns with insufficient stirrups, and the increase in section is limited.

Steel Bracing

Diagonal members placed in the bays of a frame take the lateral load directly. They increase the stiffness of the structure significantly and reduce drift. They are lighter than added shear walls, and the additional load reaching the foundations is lower. However, the bay in which they are placed becomes unusable, so they must be planned together with the architectural layout.

Steel Plate and Section Reinforcement

Plates bonded or bolted to the underside or the sides of a beam increase its flexural and shear capacity. Sections added beneath a slab can reduce the span. These solutions provide a rapid increase in capacity at member level.

Connection Details: The Heart of the Work

The most sensitive part of the calculation in steel strengthening is how the load will be transferred from the concrete to the steel. The section itself is almost never the weak link; the weak link is the connection.

  • Chemical anchors: The principal method of connecting a steel member to concrete. The anchor embedment, edge distance and cleanliness of the hole directly determine the capacity; for details see rebar dowelling our article.
  • Epoxy bonding: Used together with anchors in plate applications; it spreads the load and reduces the concentration at individual anchors.
  • Surface fit: If the concrete surface is not true, a gap remains between the steel and the concrete and the load cannot be transferred. These gaps are filled with high-strength grout.
  • Welds and bolts: The connection of steel members to one another; site welding must be carried out under controlled conditions and the weld runs must be inspected.
  • Load sharing: The existing structure is already under load. A steel member shares only the loads that arrive after it is added; this is a fact that has to be taken into account in the calculation.

Advantages

  • Speed. Fabrication is carried out in the workshop, leaving only erection on site. The curing periods of wet construction do not come into play.
  • Applicability while in use. Dust and noise are far lower than with jacketing; the work can be carried out in phases.
  • High capacity. Where required, very large increases in capacity can be achieved.
  • Light weight. The dead load added to the structure is low compared with a reinforced concrete shear wall; the need for foundation strengthening is reduced.
  • Reversibility. Work carried out with bolted connections can be dismantled or replaced if required.
  • Predictability. Steel is a homogeneous material with certified material properties; the gap between calculation and site is small.

Points to Watch

Steel has two natural weaknesses, and both must be written into the design from the outset.

Fire. Steel loses its strength rapidly at high temperatures. Strengthening members must be protected in accordance with the fire resistance period specified in the design: intumescent paint, sprayed coating or boxing in with plasterboard. This is not a detail added afterwards but part of the design.

Corrosion. Steel must be protected in damp environments, on external facades and in areas where salt is carried in, such as car parks. The surface preparation (blasting), primer and topcoat system are chosen according to the exposure class. For the application, industrial paint systems are used.

The third matter is visibility. Steel members remain exposed; if they are to be concealed architecturally, the detail must be planned early and the concealing material considered together with the fire protection. For a general assessment see steel strengthening and structural strengthening pages.

Steel, Reinforced Concrete or Carbon Fibre?

CriterionSteelReinforced concrete jacketingCarbon fibre
Application speedFastSlowVery fast
Increase in stiffnessHigh (bracing)HighLow
Increase in sectionMediumHighNegligible
Added dead loadLowHighVery low
Fire resistanceProtection requiredGoodProtection required
Applicability while in useGoodDifficultVery good
Corrosion riskYesNoneNone

In practice these methods are not rivals but complements. On a typical project, steel bracing for stiffness, carbon fibre for member capacities and, for existing damage, concrete repair are used together.

What to Watch During the Works

In steel strengthening the site stage is as decisive as the workshop fabrication. The points below ensure that a system correctly calculated in the design also works correctly on site.

  • Verification of dimensions. The actual dimensions of the existing structure may differ from those on the drawings. Site measurements must be taken before workshop fabrication begins; otherwise parts emerge that cannot be erected.
  • Surface trueness. If a gap remains between the steel member and the concrete, the load cannot be transferred. These gaps are filled with high-strength flowable grout; an interface left uncompacted renders the connection ineffective.
  • Anchor sequence. Drilling the holes, cleaning them and injecting the chemical are carried out in a particular order. Drilling a large number of holes at once and then filling them all reduces the quality of the cleaning.
  • Site welding. If welding is to be carried out, fire safety precautions must be taken and the weld runs inspected visually and, where necessary, by non-destructive methods.
  • Temporary propping. On applications that require load transfer, temporary propping must be planned for the duration of erection.
  • Protection after erection. The surface preparation and paint system must be completed immediately after erection; steel left exposed develops surface rust within a short time.

When each of these steps is recorded, it is documented that the strengthening was carried out in accordance with the design. On an erection with no records, it is almost impossible to establish the cause of a problem that emerges later.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does steel strengthening take to complete?

Fabrication and erection are assessed separately. Preparing the steel members in the workshop can take a few weeks; site erection, on the other hand, is significantly shorter than wet construction. On most projects the total time comes in below that of reinforced concrete jacketing.

Can it be applied while the building is in use?

Generally yes. There is dust and noise during the anchor drilling stage, but that stage is short and can be carried out in phases. If welding is to be done, fire safety precautions must be taken. It is a far less intrusive method than adding reinforced concrete shear walls.

Will the steel members be visible?

The work is carried out exposed; however, it can be concealed by boxing in with plasterboard or hiding it within a suspended ceiling. The concealment solution must be designed together with the fire protection; both functions can be resolved in the same detail.

How is the corrosion risk managed?

A paint system is chosen according to the exposure class: surface preparation, zinc-rich primer and a suitable topcoat. In dry interiors the risk is low; in car parks, on facades and in damp environments a protection system and periodic inspection must be planned.

How much does steel bracing affect the architecture?

The bay in which the bracing is placed is closed off; any window or route through it is affected. For this reason the layout of the bracing is determined by working structure and architecture together. A solution is usually found around stairs, lifts and blank facade grid lines.

The existing structure is already under load — how does the steel take load?

It shares the loads arriving after it is added. The existing permanent loads continue to be carried by the reinforced concrete system. On some projects load transfer can be achieved by pre-stressing or temporary propping; this is a matter that has to be addressed specifically in the calculation.

Get Expert Advice for Your Project

With over 25 years of field experience, let us determine the right solution for your building together. Contact us for a survey and quotation.

Ahmet Toka

General Manager — Likit İzolasyon

Over 25 years of field experience in waterproofing, floor coatings and structural strengthening. This article is based on applications encountered on site and the standards currently in force.

Tags:
  • #SteelStrengthening
  • #StructuralStrengthening
  • #SteelBracing
  • #Anchor
  • #Earthquake
Share: